After being robbed by the legislature and never reimbursing monies taken out of fund and never put back billions gone to whom?
May 8, 2015 § Leave a comment
The Chicago Teachers Union, or CTU, said it’s insulting to ask Chicago teachers to contribute their own money toward their retirements.
However, that setup is the standard for nearly ever other worker, government and private-sector employees alike. Retirement savings come from three components: employee contributions, employer contributions and investment returns.
But CTU officials think they should be the exception to that standard.
Chicago teachers are supposed to chip in 9% of their salary toward their retirement savings each paycheck. But currently the school district – and by extension, taxpayers – pays the majority of employees’ pension contributions. According to the Chicago Public Schools, or CPS, fiscal year 2015 budget:
“Employees also are required by statute to contribute 9% of their salary to pensions (called the ‘employee contribution’). However, CPS pays 7% of the 9% for a total of $134 million budgeted in FY15 for participants in CTPF. Non-teacher employees are part of a separate municipal pension system. CPS also pays 7% of the 8.5% employee contribution for these employees, at a cost of $40 million in FY15.”
That means requiring CPS teachers and non-teacher employees to cover the employee portion of the pension contribution would save CPS $174 million a year. And that’s just what the Chicago Board of Education has proposed.
But the CTU opposes that proposal, arguing the pickups were negotiated in the early 1980s in exchange for a salary increase. According to the Chicago Sun-Times, “The union said CPS agreed in 1981 to pay for 7% of the 9% of each CTU member’s pension contribution in lieu of a raise the board said it couldn’t afford at that time.”
But out of the nearly 30,000 CPS employees today, only about 300 worked for the district during that contract negotiation. That means only 1% of current CPS employees were actually there when the agreement was signed.
The teachers benefiting from the negotiation have done nothing wrong. But all CPS employees need to realize their employer is on the brink of financial collapse.
CPS faces a budget deficit exceeding $1 billion. Recent corruption allegations are plaguing the school board. Moody’s Investors Service issued a double-notch credit downgrade to CPS earlier this year, dropping its rating just one level above junk. And when CPS later moved forward with a bond issuance, it paid a steep penalty compared with similarly rated bonds.
Ending teacher pickups is a simple, responsible way for CPS to save $174 million. It’s not out of line to ask employees to pay their share of the costs associated with their own retirement benefits. That’s a simple standard across most industries, public and private. And the pension benefits for CPS employees are certainly on the generous side – employees can retire as early as 55 with only 20 years of service or they can choose to work longer to reach the maximum pension benefit, which equals 75% of their final average salary with automatic increases every year for life.
A $174 million reduction in CPS spending would only make a small dent in the $1.1 billion budget deficit. But it is a good example of a sensible reform than can help modernize an outdated system.
Director of Pension Reform